Hue 1968 is a book on a mission, refusing to be just another war story. One battle really did turn the vietnam war a recently published book by boston university historian cathal nolan, the allure of battle, argues that strategists, generals, and military. Jul 04, 2017 the significance of hue a gruesome, 24day battle is summed up by bowden as the moment when many americans stopped believing their governments rhetoric about the war. The battle for hue is placed in its wider perspective and is shown as a key turning point in the war. The most savage battle occurred inside the historic city. The army of the republic of vietnam and three understrength u. The battle for hue city alpha company, 1st battalion. The battle started during the communists tet offensive, when marines were surprised by a north vietnamese army attack during what was supposed to be a. A ferocious vietnam battle portrayed as a pivotal moment. Apr 12, 2018 hue 1968 is a book on a mission, refusing to be just another war story. May 30, 2017 mark bowden tries to remedy this with his excellent new book, hue 1968. As some of the nations more recent wars have helped to.
Mar 07, 2018 nicks platoon would lose 60% of its strength by the end of 15s first day of fighting. Nicks platoon would lose 60% of its strength by the end of 15s first day of fighting. Mark bowden, the author of the bestselling black hawk down, applies his. Sep 15, 2017 the battle of hue lasted for weeks and changed americans perception of the vietnam war. The fallacy of the turning point a critical look at mark. The battle of hue was by far the biggest north vietnamese success of the tet offensive, and it was the primary thrust of the offensive. The battle for hue the battle for hue was a month long battle that was part of the tet68 offensive and said to be a major turning point in the vietnam war. This book leans heavily on american accounts of the fighting. With nearly half a century of hindsight, hue deserves to be widely remembered as the single bloodiest. Bowden excels in describing the horrific urban warfare that consumed hu. The battle of hue lasted for weeks and changed americans perception of the vietnam war. Marine generals discuss lessons learned at hue, 1968.
A few weeks ago, the atlantic monthly press released mark bowdens excellent book, hue 1968, a turning point of the american war in vietnam. Mark bowdens hue 1968 recounts a battle that was a turning point in the. Located approximately 80 kilometers southeast of the dmz, hue was the predominant cultural, spiritual, and educational center of vietnam. The battle for the ancient city of hue was being fought by arvn the south vietnamese army. A compelling story of the battle of hue this book provides both a history of the battle of hue and the very personal stories of a number of people involved in the battle from all sides american, viet cong and south vietnamese. Mark bowdens searing hue 1968 finds miscalculations in. Story behind famous photograph from battle of hue during. Jun 14, 2018 battle of hue thong tu gate part 3 tet 1968 vietnam war then and now duration.
A turning point of the american war in vietnam by mark. The photo appeared in the march 8 edition of life magazine, spread across two full pages in a sixpage section of color photos from the battle, according to mark bowdens 2017 book, hue 1968. Though the jungle fighting of the vietnam war has been closely examined, the incity, housetohouse combat characterized by the battle for hue during tet 1968 had never been covered extensively before the publication of this debut by nowwellknown vietnam war chronicler keith william nolan. In 1968 the north vietnamese and their viet cong allies staged attacks across south vietnam during.
The heart and soul of hue 1968 lies with its vivid and often wrenching descriptions of the storm of war as soldiers and south vietnamese citizens experienced it. The struggle for huestalemate in the old city chapter 12. His new book, hue 1968, is about the single bloodiest battle of the vietnam war, launched when north vietnamese army and viet cong forces attacked several cities as part of what became known collectively as the tet offensive. Tet 1968 paperback june 1, 1996 by keith nolan author 4. The city comprises two distinct towns separated by the perfume river, which flows from west to east. In he offers a wellbalanced history of the players in this historic battle that as he. A turning point of the american war in vietnam, the new book from mark bowden of the atlantic, tells the tactical narrative of these events splendidly albeit with a dubious epilogue focused on broader questions of strategy and foreign policy. He reported at the philadelphia inquirer for twenty. Although many photographs and two maps enhance the story of the battle, the map of hue city is marred by the book binding which runs right across the southern part of the perfume river, obliterating most of the things that the reader will want to see. Jun 06, 2017 with nearly half a century of hindsight, hue deserves to be widely remembered as the single bloodiest battle of the war, one of its defining moments, and one of the most intense urban combat. The battle for hue, part of the tet offensive, started with an assault by communist forces in the wee hours of jan. Mark bowden takes a deep dive into the bloodiest battle of the vietnam war.
With nearly half a century of hindsight, hue deserves to be widely remembered as the single bloodiest battle of the war, one of its defining moments. The book is the culmination of a sevenyear project of articles from the vfw magazine. A topnotch account of the battle for hue during the tet offensive in 1968. Jul 15, 2017 mark bowdens hue 1968, a thoroughly researched and compelling new account of the most controversial battle of the tet offensive in vietnam, might be taken as a kind of rejoinder to nolans book. The film is based on vietnam veteran gustav hasford s semiautobiographical 1979 novel the shorttimers, part of which is also set during the. Each chapter focuses on a specific battle and there are separate chapters on the naval and air wars.
Its been two weeks into the tet offensive in hue, and the fighting continues north of the perfume river inside the citadel. Keith nolan was the best nonfiction writer on the vietnam war. The struggle for hue the taking of the citadel and aftermath the battle for hue, 1968 by james h. After eleven days of fighting, the marines have now secured the southern part of hue south of the perfume river. I believe this was his first book, and it set the tone for his subsequent works. The struggle for hue stalemate in the old city chapter 12. Shortly after the battle, i was moved on by 7th comm to another assignment. This book also shows how the situation in hue was a reflection of the wider deception of the public by the military top brass and politicians regarding the wars progress.
Battle of hue thong tu gate part 3 tet 1968 vietnam war then and now duration. Mark bowdens hue 1968, a thoroughly researched and compelling new account of the most controversial battle of the tet offensive in vietnam, might be taken as a kind of rejoinder to nolans book. Jun 16, 2011 i am doing a project on the battle of hue for school, it is a really important project because it accounts for more than half of my final mark in the leaving certificate which is like sats or a levels can you please suggest some books about the battle that are written by either by famous historians or first hand accounts like diaries. It is incredible that hammel could achieve the detail he did. Bowden points out that the tet offensive campaign, of which hue was the major battle, was a strategic surprise. The battle started during the communists tet offensive, when marines were surprised by a north vietnamese army attack during what was supposed to be a ceasefire negotiated for a vietnamese holiday. Among the population, 5,800 civilians were reported killed or missing. He was inspired to create this piece by reading a book called phase line green written by nicholas warr, a veteran of vietnam and hue city, which reads a very detailed occurrence of the battle in the citadel that month of february. Bowden points out that the tet offensive campaign, of which hue was the major battle, was a strategic surprise that.
During fighting within hue city in february 1968, u. Winner of the 2018 marine corps heritage foundation greene award for a distinguished work of nonfiction. Nolan did his homework and spoke with many participants of the battle. Opinion learning from the hue massacre the new york times. The former imperial capital of vietnam, hue was defended by the army.
The peoples army of vietnam had amassed 10,000 troops outside hue to take that city. Though the jungle fighting of the vietnam war has been closely examined, the incity, housetohouse combat characterized by the battle for hue during tet 1968 had never been covered extensively before the publication of this debut by nowwell. The significance of hue a gruesome, 24day battle is summed up by bowden as the moment when many americans stopped believing their governments rhetoric about the war. How an nfl lineman changed the course of the battle of hue. On the second day of the battle, a battalion from the u. The film is based on vietnam veteran gustav hasford s semiautobiographical 1979 novel the shorttimers, part of which is also set during the battle of hu. Instead of simply chronicling the plight of those caught up in it, bowden is bent on convincing the reader that the battle was not only very consequential but overseen by a foolish top leadership. His most ambitious work yet, hue 1968 is the story of the centerpiece of the tet offensive and a turning point in the american war in vietnam.
See all 10 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. A masterful bloodandguts account of the decisive battle in the vietnam war. In bowdens retelling, the weekslong siege at hue helped alter the course of the war. The battle of hue has come to be regarded as one of the most infamous urban battles in marine corps history. Altschuler, minneapolis startribune mark bowdens book hue 1968 is a. This book is absolutely accurate in its record of the fighting in hue. The battle for hue city alpha company, 1st battalion, 5th.
The battle comprises the second half of stanley kubrick s 1987 film full metal jacket. As befitting a battle history of this kind, the book has relatively little to say about the broader political and military context in which the encounter in hue occurred. Feb 09, 2015 battlefield documentaries 555,086 views. Online shopping from a great selection at books store. The true story of the marine on the tank and one of the.
The battle for hue, just like the beginning of the tet68 offensive took everyone by surprise for it occurred on jan 31, 1968 during the beginning of the lunar new year one of vietnameses most scared holidays. Thats my father in the backi purchased several of these books as keepsakes. The battle in hue lasted weeks and involved devastating u. Anyone wanting an explicit description of the fiercest battle and longest battle of the vietnam war should read this book.
It was an agonizing struggle to wrest the entrenched and wellsupplied enemy from the imperial city. The marines battle to recapture hue on the fourth day of the fighting, the united states iii marine amphibious force managed to establish a command post in the macv compound. The end of january 2018 and the beginning of february 2018 mark the 50th anniversary of the tet offensive and the battle of hue. Hue 1968 a turning point of the american war in vietnam by mark bowden illustrated. The epic battle for hue left much of the ancient city a pile of rubble as 40 percent of its buildings were destroyed, leaving some 116,000 civilians homeless. The struggle for huethe taking of the citadel and aftermath the battle for hue, 1968 by james h. Marine corps battalions attacked and defeated more than 10,000 entrenched peoples army of vietnam pavn and national front for the liberation of south vietnam nlf, also known as, viet cong guerrilla forces. Home battle of hue, 1968 libguides at soldier support. The author of black hawk down explains why the battle of hue was a. In his latest dazzling book about americans at war, journalist mark bowden proposes a fresh and provocative, if not entirely convincing, answer. Robbins provides an antidote to the flawed tet mythology still shaping the perceptions of american military conflicts against unconventional enemies and haunting our troops in combat.
Two marine corps companies were directed to begin the painstaking process of clearing the south side of hue building by building, through the prepared defenses of a determined enemy. Sad to have to read what happened as he will never talk about. Jun 22, 2017 as befitting a battle history of this kind, the book has relatively little to say about the broader political and military context in which the encounter in hue occurred. Parts of the book are very graphic descriptions that were sometimes hard to listen to. It is a dramatic and very detailed dio constructed by steven zuleski. Mark bowden tries to remedy this with his excellent new book, hue 1968. Mark bowdens searing hue 1968 finds miscalculations in the.